Culture and Community

Origins Through the Long 19th Century

September 9, 1636

Brown set sail with emigrants seeking freedom to practice Protestant faith

Andrew Brown’s efforts in emigration suggests that some deaf people succeed in doing so and forms small communities afterwards, with engaging in religious activities becoming part of their culture.

Keywords

Emigration, Religious Practice, Community Forming

Sources

Harry Lang, “Genesis of a Community: The American Deaf Experience in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” Deaf History Reader, 3.

 

1775 - 1783

Revolutionary War

American Patriots fight to escape British rule and establish autonomous control over American colonies. Aided by France, the rebelling colonists achieve independence, but not without consequence: thousands of soldiers die in battle, and over twice as many die from disease. Many more are injured or disabled, including a significant number who become deaf due to artillery and disease. These deaf veterans return home from war with access barriers between them and their previous lives.

Keywords

Revolutionary War, Acquired Deafness

Sources

 “Revolutionary War,” History.com, June 2024, https://www.history.com/topics/american-revolution/american-revolution-history.

 “American Revolution Facts,” American Battlefield Trust, 2024, https://www.battlefields.org/learn/articles/american-revolution-faqs#:~:text=Throughout%20the%20course%20of%20the%20war%2C%20an%20estimated%206%2C800%20Americans,died%20while%20prisoners%20of%20war.

 Harry Lang, “Genesis of a Community: The American Deaf Experience in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” essay, in Deaf History Reader, 1–23, 14.

1776 - 1783

Pennsylvania Magazine Publishes Manual Alphabet

ThePennsylvania Magazine publishes graphics of a two-handed manual alphabet called “Dumb Speech.” The magazine identifies some of the benefits of this manual alphabet as being quick to learn and capable of conveying thoughts and ideas faster than “even the most skillful artist can write…with pen and ink.” This publication is evidence that fingerspelling was used in colonial America by both hearing and deaf colonists, suggesting that deafness didn’t obstruct deaf individuals’ participation in society. 

Keywords

Manual Alphabet, Sign Language, Colonial Deaf Experience

Sources

Harry Lang, “Genesis of a Community: The American Deaf Experience in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” essay, in Deaf History Reader, 1–23, 10.

1777 - 1783

The exemption of Joshua Graves during the Revolutionary War

The government exempts Joshua Graves from military duty due to his deafness. He then clears and plants acres of land to live. His experiences give insights on deaf lives during the Revolutionary War, in terms of military and regular life.

Keywords

Revolutionary War, Deaf Life

Sources

Harry Lang, “Genesis of a Community: The American Deaf Experience in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” Deaf History Reader, 13.

 

1817 - 1783

Opening of the American School for the Deaf

Thomas Gallaudet, with the assistance of Laurent Clerc, opens the school in Hartford, Connecticut as a place to teach both academic and vocational topics, along with sign language to deaf students as an outlet to communicate. The opening of school illuminates the importance of education to deaf culture and allows students to establish a strong community. However, the school excludes both women and Black students: highlighting prejudices commonly seen within deaf culture.

Keywords

American Sign Language, Sexism, Racism, Academic Training, Vocational Training

Sources

Robert Buchanan, “Building Independence,”  Illusions of Equality, (Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press, 1999), 1-19.

1847

“The Mute’s Lament”

American deaf writer John Carlin, expresses an inferiority complex, internalizing the perspective of the hearing world. Reflecting other deaf author’s overshadowed pride, as the hearing world seeks to fix them to allow integration into society. Causing an overall battle between gratification and feeling inferior. Carlin speaks for himself in this poem but embodies the dilemma of the community trying to understand their value with the burden of the hearing world’s standards.

 

Keywords

Deaf double consciousness, author

Sources

Christopher Krentz, “A Sense of Two-ness: Deaf Double Consciousness at Midcentury,” in Writing Deafness (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2007), 137 -138.

1858

Equal Futures

Debate emerges about the Deaf-Mute community’s future. Letters explore their placement and societal roles. Mr. Flournoy supports creating a separate community. Seeking to address marginalization created by education gaps. Change is attainable. Efforts highlight the community’s innate worth. Advocacy emphasizes equality and inclusion. Deaf individuals deserve recognition and opportunities. Society benefits when all contribute simultaneously.

Keywords

Community, class, communication

Sources

Booth, E., and J. J. Flournoy. “MR. FLOURNOY’S PLAN FOR A DEAF-MUTE COMMONWEALTH.” JSTOR – Persistent Links for Library Resources – Research Guides at University of Oregon Libraries, Jan. 1858, 40-45.

1858

Deaf Commonwealth Letters

Due to prejudices, deaf American authors John Flournoy and Edmund Booth debate the best place for their community. Flournoy advocates for emigration; allowing sign to be taught and sovereignty. Booth finds it improbable due to illiteracy. This debate splits the community, their intelligence and ability to be educated is questioned, revealing the view the deaf have on their own people. Noting the effects of prejudice on the deaf which shapes their identity and aspirations.



Keywords

Identity, emigration

Sources

Flournoy, JJ. “On Planning a Deaf-Mute Commonwealth.” 1858. [and responses], pp. 13-26.

1876

Susan B. Anthony and Matilda Joslyn Gage Present a "Declaration for the Rights of Women" to the Vice President

Women’s Rights Activists, Susan B. Anthony and Matilda Joslyn Gage disrupt the Centennial Celebration of the U.S. to challenge the exclusion of women from fundamental rights. Showcasing that a celebration for a country built upon liberty and justice does not include those ideals for women. This effort allowed for significant progression in the women’s suffrage movement.

Keywords

Women's rights, gender bias, equality

Sources

National Women’s History Museum. “Timeline of Woman Suffrage.” Women’s History. Accessed January 7, 2025. https://www.womenshistory.org/exhibits/timeline-woman-suffrage.

 

Robert Buchanan, “Building Independence,” In Illusions of Equality (Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press, 1999), 1-19. Pg 12. 

August 25, 1880 - August 27, 1880

The First National Convention for the Deaf

Board members of the National Association for the Deaf hold the First National Convention in Cincinnati, Ohio—a scribe documents minutes. Deaf community members present the needs of the deaf as a class. These needs include building a strong community, the workforce, education, and religion. The conference is still held in the 21st century.

Keywords

first national convention, education, deaf community, religion

Sources

National Association of the Deaf, Proceedings of the First National Convention of Deaf-Mutes Held in Cincinnati, Ohio (New York: Printed at the New York Institution for the Deaf and Dumb, 1889), 1–35. 

1880 - August 27, 1880

The First National Convention of Deaf-Mutes Meet in Cincinnati, Ohio

The First National Convention of Deaf-Mutes meet to discuss vocational training, Christian religion, and the community as a whole: critical pieces of deaf culture. Speakers present different ideas on each of the topics in an effort to advocate for changes within the deaf community while still maintaining important pieces of deaf culture. This convention shows the desire to improve the class level of the deaf community within Reconstruction America.

Keywords

Culture, Community, Class, Vocational Training, Christianity, Education

Sources

National Association of the Deaf. Proceedings of the First National Convention of Deaf-Mutes, (New York: Printed at the New York Institution for the Deaf and Dumb, 1880), 1-40.

1887

Women Can Apply to Gallaudet College

Laurie Sheridan, Angie Fuller, and Georgia Elliot, activists for deaf women, aid in the allowance of women to apply to Gallaudet College — in Washington D.C.. Women have the chance to educate themselves on other trades than domestic ones and join the same workforce as men.

Keywords

women's rights, education, equality

Sources

Robert Buchanan, “Building Independence,” In Illusions of Equality (Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press, 1999), 1-19. Pg 8. 

1893

An Articulation Class

Teachers at the Illinois Institution for the Education of the Deaf and Dumb train students to enunciate and speak vocally. This oralist practice, emerging after the Civil War, seeks to assimilate Deaf individuals into hegemonic white hearing norms; marginalizing American Sign Language and Deaf culture while reinforcing hearing behaviors as the standard.

Keywords

Education, Oralism, Assimilation

Sources

Christopher Krentz, “A Sense of Two-ness: Deaf Double Consciousness at Midcentury,” in Writing Deafness (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2007), 131-169, 135.

1896

Deaf Students at Gallaudet College

Students at Gallaudet College, the first for Deaf individuals, challenge the Oralist movement by asserting their identity. This photograph marks a pivotal moment in Deaf culture, highlighting their fight for education, dignity, and cultural pride against imposed white, hearing-centric norms.

Keywords

Culture, Movement, Education

Sources

Christopher Krentz, “A Sense of Two-ness: Deaf Double Consciousness at Midcentury,” in Writing Deafness (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2007), 131-169, 157.

1896 - August 27, 1880

Verdict in the Plessy V. Ferguson Case

The Supreme Court rules against Plessy’s, who is ⅛ Black, claim that his refusal to move from white seating violates the 13th and 14th amendment. This ruling enforces the ideas of “separate but equal” and racial segregation in the US: showing racism’s prevalence in American culture. This ruling perpetuates inferior education and facilities along with poor treatment for Black citizens

Keywords

Segregation, “separate but equal”, Racism

Sources

Brian Duignan, “Plessy v. Ferguson,” Encyclopedia Britannica, (December 17, 2024). https://www.britannica.com/event/Plessy-v-Ferguson-1896

1903

Deaf Philosopher Argues Against Oralism

Douglas Tilden’s Reflections, published in the deaf newspaper The Silent Worker, displays both his and the newspaper’s opposition to the oralist movement, which has grown in popularity in recent decades. Tilden demonstrates a reluctance to abandon sign language and a skepticism of oralist Institutions for the Deaf. His beliefs are representative of a broader belief that assimilation to a hearing world limits the potential for deaf people to succeed and build community. 

Keywords

Douglas Tilden, The Silent Worker, oralism, sign language, Institutions, assimilation, deaf community

Sources

Douglas Tilden, “Reflections of a Deaf-Mute Philosopher,” in Deaf American Prose, p. 122-5.

December 1903

Tilden Publishes “Reflection of a Deaf-Mute Philosopher”

Douglas Tilden critiques on deaf people, their lives, and their interactions with hearing people in America by publishing his work, encouraging the integration of the deaf and hearing communities.

Keywords

Community Forming, assimilation, Douglas Tilden

Sources

Douglas Tilden, “Reflections of a Deaf-Mute Philosopher”, Deaf American Prose, 122-125.

1952

Black Skin, White Masks by Frantz Fanon

Parallel to the deaf community is the dynamic between black Algerians under French colonial rule. The “whiter” the Algerians are, the more “human”, this “white-ness” came in the form of speaking the French language. Mirroring the oralist movement, seeking to assimilate the deaf by banning sign, and teaching them to speak. Morphing their identity to follow the norms of the hearing society. Destroying the community, by taking away the ability to communicate with each other.



Keywords

French colonialism, oralism movement, language

Sources

Christopher Krentz, “A Sense of Two-ness: Deaf Double Consciousness at Midcentury,” in Writing Deafness (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2007), 134.